Hello everyone! Another Regional is in the books, and this one is a bit unique in the sheer number of players calling for the death of the format in which it occurred. That may be a bit of an overstatement colored in recency bias, but the calls for Lusamine’s banning, or some other remedy for the environment that has allowed mill decks to attain a foothold in the game, are gradually building in volume. Of course, we didn’t actually see any of these mill decks make Top 8 in Roanoke this weekend—perhaps telling itself—but the specter of these decks has nonetheless shaped the Lost Thunder format in a profound way moving forward.
Generally speaking, these sort of “annoying” decks tend to be particularly prominent in terms of local event concentration, so if I were you, I’d expect to see a healthy supply of them at your upcoming Cups and Challenges. For whatever reason, players do seem to back it off sometimes when it comes to mill decks at the major tournaments, but there’s never any such inhibition at the local level—it could be an interesting couple of weeks.
In addition to those local events, we have a Regional in Australia this weekend, a Special Event in Chile next weekend, and Harrogate/Anaheim Regionals immediately following to round out the 2018 Tier 2 circuit. Without a doubt, there’s a lot of CP up for grabs over the next few weeks at all levels. In my mind, a key to earning it will be dealing with these mill menaces, so I’m going to take today’s article to cover that specter from a few different angles.
Roanoke Recap: The Mill’s Manifestation
While I was in attendance in Roanoke this weekend, I don’t have any sort of report or anything of that nature to offer—after being asked on Friday afternoon, I was added to the event’s judging staff (or, added back—long story). I spent the weekend floating between the stream and the floor, meaning the prep I’d done for the tournament wasn’t put to the test. Nevertheless, before I got that email on Friday, I was planning to play either Blacephalon-GX or Regigigas/Hoopa for the weekend, so I have some decent content to cover provided how the weekend went.
When Alex and I got to Roanoke, and in our discussions prior, Regigigas—by my understanding, inspired by Michael Catron—was the deck we had our eyes on for the weekend. It seemed on paper as though much of the format would be unable to deal with a sea of 180 HP 1-Prizers, and that was attractive to be sure. We went as far as actually acquiring the Regigigas at the venue before testing the matchup that concerned me the most: Malamar. Stable, gimmick-free Energy Acceleration has always been the antithesis of mill, and this proved no exception in our testing on Friday. It was possible to sneak games out, sure, but it wasn’t comfortable.
That led to an important question: how important was it to beat Malamar? In my eyes, it was a pretty essential consideration. Given the early season success of Malamar/Shrine in the United States, and the United States’ historical tendency to pay more attention to what happens here than what happens elsewhere, I wasn’t convinced the Latin America results would be enough to convince people to leave their P Energy at home—or, at least, to do so in enough mass to remove the problem. On the other hand, a dirty secret of mill decks is that players who don’t know what they’re doing in the matchup can find a way to a loss regardless of what they’re playing, and there’s a realistic correlation between playing out-of-date decks and having difficulty in unforeseen matchups.
Now, that’s not remotely to say Malamar was an out-of-date deck, per se: Jason Annichiarico, Beckett Pierce, and others demonstrated that with their innovative takes on the list. But, my concern was with the remnants of early-season style Malamar/Shrine—and that, I don’t think there’s much argument, was outdated. In hindsight, I think I was right to be concerned about that matchup, as Malamar seemed big enough in the room to have been a potential problem. We’ll probably know more via the RK9 meta breakdown soon.
To get back on the subject of mill, the fact that Malamar was not meshing well with our reality shifted the focus toward Blacephalon, championed to my brother by Wes Hollenberg. A few techs were tossed around in the name of beating mill, though in the end they ended up going without. I’m not honestly sure how many mill either of the pair (or Ian Robb, who I understand was involved as well) hit in the end, but Blacephalon does have the advantage of being a deck with two implicit advantages against the genre: limitless damage and built-in energy acceleration. In the end, Alex landed 9th with the Blacephalon list they came up with.
Had I played, I probably would’ve played Blacephalon as well, but Regigigas would’ve been a close consideration too, with this list being most probable:
2 Mount Lanakila
****** Pokémon Trading Card Game Deck List ******
##Pokémon - 11
##Trainer Cards - 48
* 2 Mount Lanakila BUS 118
* 1 Shrine of Punishment CES 143
* 4 Steven’s Resolve CES 145
* 4 Cynthia UPR 119
* 4 Acerola BUS 112
* 3 Lusamine CIN 96
* 4 Plumeria BUS 120
* 2 Gladion CIN 95
* 1 Guzma BUS 115
* 1 Faba LOT 173
* 2 Enhanced Hammer GRI 124
* 3 Ancient Crystal UPR 118
* 2 Rescue Stretcher BUS 165
* 4 Max Potion GRI 128
* 4 Crushing Hammer SUM 115
* 3 Counter Catcher CIN 91
* 2 Choice Helmet LOT 169
* 1 Switch SUM 132
* 1 Nest Ball SUM 123
##Energy - 1
* 1 Rainbow Energy HS 104
Total Cards - 60
****** via SixPrizes: https://sixprizes.com/?p=71858 ******
Moving forward, increased Faba counts could be an interesting spin, as despite my prior attacks on the card’s existence, it’s found a solid niche in the mill mirror business. Else, there’s only so much you can innovate here. A consideration of mine, though, is the Mt. Coronet/Metal strategy that certain archetypes have successfully employed in defense against mill. Plumeria is often a key to keeping your game plan afloat, but at the same time, is often counterproductive to your need for resources or buildup to an Unown Hand victory. A configuration with M Energy could be useful in this vein, but it’s a pretty radical consideration, so I’m not yet sure what all I think would need to fall in place to make it viable.
With that all said, I’m going to move into talking mill more generally: what makes it viable, and what this format can do to stop it.
Mill’s MO: Why it Works
Here’s the highlights on mill in my mind, and why it’s something that’s cropped up in today’s era:
- This is a take asking to be a bit controversial, yes, but nevertheless: as I alluded earlier, a significant portion of mill’s ability to succeed comes from players who aren’t prepared to deal with its tricks. This preparation can manifest in both the construction of a list and the way a player approaches the matchup—the latter is usually the more important consideration in an average tournament match, though, with the way lists have become fairly universally known.
- This is part of why, in my mind, mill did not succeed in Day 2 this weekend. The players had lists more prepared for it, yes, but they also were likely more practiced against it as well.
- A key detail of this: testing mill is a pretty miserable experience by most folks’ standards. This is double edged: it makes it harder for players to prepare against mill and it makes mill better, by definition. Effective testing groups generally just grind it out, as miserable as it may be. With that said, you don’t need to play a ton to get a feel for the matchup. The major point I’m making here is that part of mill’s success is a lack of preparation among the player base. This is something you can personally attempt to guard against merely by playing against competent mill a good number of times. Know where common pitfalls lie, understand your resource management, etc.
- Right now, we’re at a unique point in the genre’s history. In the past, a player who was determined to do so could stall out a series against mill merely by playing to do so. In Top Cut, a scenario that often presented itself was a mill deck winning Game 1, losing to the 4 Prize Rule in Game 2, and naturally losing sudden death. The 4 Prize Rule is gone, Sudden Death is now Tiebreaker Games, and most of all…Unown Hand. Playing a passive game against mill no longer works because you’ll simply lose.
- A number of decks are reliant on single turn-by-turn attachments, or, worse, Double Colorless Energy for their attacking, and decks with built-in energy acceleration are at a low point. Furthermore, decks that can hit sky-high numbers on demand reliably are at an even lower point. I think it’d be emblematic of a healthy format if not for the fact that nobody really seems to like playing against mill.
- Worse, in my opinion, is watching mill. Go watch Round 9 from Roanoke and tell me that’s enjoyable content for more than the last 2 minutes. Personally, I’m not a huge fan.
- Overall, a combination of resource availability, the nature of the format’s attackers, and the metagame’s evolution, it’s quite the situation that’s arisen, so now the subject of greater importance: beating mill.your
Techs for Mastering the Menace
I want to talk some general tips for dealing with these attrition-based matchups, then get into some cards that the current format offers a few specific decks for turning the tables on the mill menace. I guess it’s probably worth clarifying, most of the way into this article, that my definition of mill today steps away from the Zoroark/Control and is more focused on the concept traditionally-known more as a “stall” sort of thing. I can hear a trading card game purist out there somewhere very upset with my lack of specificity on this distinction, but the passive mill is where we’re at in Pokémon right now, so it’s the terminology I’m running with.
So, does your deck have access to Beast Ring? Really want some Energy back from the discard pile? Electrode might be your man. Considering stall is entirely unconcerned with Prize cards, giving away 2 at the cost of getting 5 Energy cards back is a very solid trade, and helpfully, Ditto p’s release in Lost Thunder has made it easier than ever to play strange Stage 1s in ways never before considered.
While Electrode does facilitate some energy recovery, that’s actually not the primary use I’ve imagined for its abilities at this current stage in time. Instead, there are two primary other uses:
- In decks that play Beast Ring, you can place force your opponent to 4 Prizes, enabling the use of the acceleration. In addition to the energy from Electrode itself, this is a solid way to ensure a flow of energy throughout the game, and is something a deck like Buzzwole might be able to explore and exploit to decent effect—imagine permanent Sledgehammer turns, too.
- In a deck like Zoroark/Control, detonating Electrode removes the specter of Counter Catcher from your opponent’s arsenal for a time, and can place a position where you park an Oranguru active and instead attempt to deck your opponent out—or, play Unown Hand yourself and take matters into your own control. Imagine an Oranguru with 4 Double Colorless Energy. There’s potential here.
This is probably a Blacephalon-only special, probably, though any deck with Ditto could be compatible if you’re feeling particularly daring. Stinger-GX was noted as a cute trick early in its existence, but now it can have second life as anti-mill propaganda. There are a few notable issues, such as getting 3 Energy onto Naganadel or Ditto while under Plumeria siege, but it very thoroughly simplifies the process of winning the game: 3 Prizes is less than 6, and once more, you’re entirely unconcerned with your opponent’s activities when it relates to Prize cards.
The significant extra benefit here is Beast Ring, which is what makes this option attractive to Blacephalon and Buzzwole players alike—even certain Malamar lists could probably get in on the fun here, though it’s probably not entirely necessary. 3 Prizes is wonderfully compatible in that scenario, though admittedly it’s not quite as wonderful as Electrode’s 4 in Buzzwole’s case.
As an added bonus, in decks that already feature Ultra Beasts, Naganandel can be a legitimate way to deal with Buzzwole storms in a manner that’s energy efficient and easily recoverable with Acerola later, given Buzzwole probably won’t return a 1HKO. Psychic has never been a bad typing, and I don’t expect that’s going to change through the rest of the Lost Thunder meta.
This is a very general-purpose option, enabling any number of decks to beat mill/stall at its own game. Without a sea of Acerola, even the 70 damage Girafarig can offer eventually adds up. In the Round 9 Roanoke match I mentioned earlier, this was the strategy Frank Percic pursued against Regigigas/Hoopa in Game 1. It didn’t work out for him in the end, but a pair of Lusamine and a Mars would’ve done wonders in this sense. Even in other decks, disrupting the Lusamine chain in any manner can often be enough to throw mill off balance, and that’s often all you need to pull a win out.
In my current view, Girafarig is the potential answer to a lot of interesting dilemmas currently facing the Standard format, and I’d be unsurprised to see it start to slowly take hold as a mainstay within the area as we continue to move forward in the format. Most local format evolution is going to be slowed as we move through a period of weeks without any super-large Standard tournaments, but I’m curious to see if this holds true moving forward into December.
Final Words on Standard
A few final thoughts on Standard:
- Blacephalon and Gardevoir were easily the winners of the weekend, and that’s not surprising considering their propensity for destroying the mill decks I’ve referred to today. I was thoroughly impressed watching the Gardevoir/Solgaleo/Swampert concept this weekend, and the number of things it could pull off is unmatched elsewhere in the format. Blacephalon isn’t going to go anywhere fast, and overall, I’d expect this weekend’s top choices to have more top-table staying power than the Zoroark/Control we saw in Brazil.
- Speaking of Zoroark/Control, not too shocking to see it slip back to the edges of the realm of competitive sphere, but don’t be surprised to see a take come roaring back over the next few weekends. Zoroark is still a broken card, and the number of options at its disposal is still unmatched in the game.
- Decidueye-GX is another winner on the weekend, seeing its first major-scale play in some time. Former 6P writer Alex Hill is surely thrilled, but it’s incredible to see the diversity that’s evolved from certain areas of the format while the mill menace rages on the other side.
- Alolan Ninetales-GX, the glue that’s made much of the above possible, is one of the crazier cards printed in recent memory—certainly, it’s met the hype. To say the least, if you don’t own your set yet, that’s probably something to remedy ASAP, because its involvement in the Standard format is only going to ramp up. (With that said, I’m not sure how much of an Expanded player it’ll manage to be.)
That’s all from me today. Hopefully this helps you evaluate your options moving forward, and as always, feel free to reach out with any discussion on 6P as a whole.
Wishing you the best,
…and that will conclude this Unlocked Underground article.
After 45 days, we unlock each Underground (UG/★) article for public viewing. New articles are reserved for Underground members.
Underground Members: Thank you for making this article possible!
Other Readers: Check out the FAQ if you are interested in joining Underground and gaining full access to our latest content.