The “Evolutions” of the Metagame

A deck really only has a "surprise factor" if it hasn't seen play at all before much like Ross was at Worlds last year. Something like 6 Conors may not be heavily teched against but we've all logged enough games against the deck and familiar enough with it that it really doesn't have any surprise factor at all.
 
A deck really only has a "surprise factor" if it hasn't seen play at all before much like Ross was at Worlds last year. Something like 6 Conors may not be heavily teched against but we've all logged enough games against the deck and familiar enough with it that it really doesn't have any surprise factor at all.

A deck that was popular in the past doesn't have as much of the shock factor as a full-on rogue, but it does carry the advantage of being unexpected. At Fall Regionals, a good number of TyRam decks that won ran either Kingdra Prime or Magnezone Prime, both of which were primarily to swing the "lock" matchups like The Truth. Had they not ran these techs, I doubt they all would have won their respective events.

Not being teched against is a pretty big advantage and can go a long way, not to mention people running decks that maybe don't have a good matchup against your deck because it isn't popular. People are a lot more willing to write off an auto-loss that's tier 2 than tier 1. Simply put, the meta won't be as prepared for you, which is an advantage that's pretty tough to overestimate.
 
I don't think the Fall Regionals example is a good one. Typhlosion/Magnezone in particular (and to a lesser extent Typhlosion Kingdra) were just better versions of Typhlosion/Reshiram. IMO, Typhlosion/Magnezone was the best deck played at Fall Regionals. I don't think it won at all because of the surprise factor, but rather that it was just a better version of one of the best decks in formats that most people somehow overlooked.
 
I don't think the Fall Regionals example is a good one. Typhlosion/Magnezone in particular (and to a lesser extent Typhlosion Kingdra) were just better versions of Typhlosion/Reshiram. IMO, Typhlosion/Magnezone was the best deck played at Fall Regionals. I don't think it won at all because of the surprise factor, but rather that it was just a better version of one of the best decks in formats that most people somehow overlooked.

Yes, I do agree with you, Charranitar. I didn't mean Kingdra/TyRam or Magne/Tyram won because of the surprise factor, I meant that a big part of their success was that they did a great job preparing for the meta. 130 HP Barrier was a significant issue for TyRam and ZPST lists at the time, so they ran Kingdra/Magnezone to deal with that. Had they not run those backup Stage 2's, their Ross match up would have been more difficult, so I believe the inclusion of Kingdra/Magnezone played a bit part in their winning the event.

My point was that if you're running a lower tier, but still competitive deck (yes, they are out there!), you'll have the advantage of players not running hard counters to your deck.
 
Its not a "surprise" though. A "surprise" factor is more for a deck that has never seen play before and people really don't know how to play against it. Ross at Worlds in 2011, Gyarados and Flygon/Machamp at Worlds 2009. LuxApe at Nationals in 2009, Queendom in 2005, oh and of course Team Magma in 2004 are all prime examples of this. Fulop even made the comment that he didn't think that Team Magma decks were considerably better than Blaziken rather the Blaziken player just didn't know how to play against them. These are all prime examples of decks that did well because of a surprise factor.
 
Like I said, they're not full-fledged rogues, but I they do carry an advantageous "surprise" factor, even if they were popular in the past. The point is they aren't popular now, so people will be more willing to play decks with an auto-loss to yours and less techs geared towards beating you.

The meta is constantly changing and shifting and, usually before most people even realize it, a deck that was considered "past its prime" can suddenly become a very viable option, just because the BDIF happens to be a favorable match up. Donphan variants were able to capture several City Championships because EelZone had become the BDIF. Even though Donphan was a known deck (received quite a bit of pre-Worlds hype as well), but it was unexpected and Eels lists weren't prepared for it; they knew it existed in the format, but had written off that auto-loss. If Donphan had been more popular, more people might have run Tornadus or even Yanmega, but since it wasn't, they were completely blindsided.

The decks in the article aren't end-all, take to any event decks, but plays to counter and and catch the meta off guard.
 
We will agree to disagree than. I won't lie and I took some offense to your match ups basically saying the 3 decks you discussed have positive Zekrom/Eel match ups is pretty...you have more confidence in those match ups than I do. As a Zekrom/Eel player I find all 3 of them to be extremely positive match ups. I'm not trying to hate, but I feel it is extremely important to be realistic when it comes to match ups heading into a big tournament. I think Landorus/Terrakion is a winnable match up for Zekrom/Eel but I would never call it positive.
 
We will agree to disagree than. I won't lie and I took some offense to your match ups basically saying the 3 decks you discussed have positive Zekrom/Eel match ups is pretty...you have more confidence in those match ups than I do. As a Zekrom/Eel player I find all 3 of them to be extremely positive match ups. I'm not trying to hate, but I feel it is extremely important to be realistic when it comes to match ups heading into a big tournament. I think Landorus/Terrakion is a winnable match up for Zekrom/Eel but I would never call it positive.

Yeah, otherwise we'll fill up page after page going back and forth :P

Zeels is one of my favorite decks in the format and I've logged a ton of games both with and against it, but in general, a deck that can consistently churn out "big" fighting Pokemon is going to have a big advantage over the lightning-based Zeels. I don't think any of those match ups I specified is being unrealistic; to achieve those kinds of results, do you have to thoroughly know the match up? Yes, but that's true with any deck and once you do, they are certainly attainable.
 
Yeah, otherwise we'll fill up page after page going back and forth :P

Zeels is one of my favorite decks in the format and I've logged a ton of games both with and against it, but in general, a deck that can consistently churn out "big" fighting Pokemon is going to have a big advantage over the lightning-based Zeels. I don't think any of those match ups I specified is being unrealistic; to achieve those kinds of results, do you have to thoroughly know the match up? Yes, but that's true with any deck and once you do, they are certainly attainable.

"Attainable," but not positive. I agree that "'big' fighting pokemon" have an advantage against most varieties of Zeels decks, but the win is still attainable for Zeels.

However, for sure, Typhlosion and Vileplume/Reuniclus variants don't at all have positive matchups against Zeels for sure, even if the win IS attainable.
 
"Attainable," but not positive. I agree that "'big' fighting pokemon" have an advantage against most varieties of Zeels decks, but the win is still attainable for Zeels.

However, for sure, Typhlosion and Vileplume/Reuniclus variants don't at all have positive matchups against Zeels for sure, even if the win IS attainable.

Yeah, I never meant to suggest Zeels has a positive matchup against "big fighting decks", even if it isn't completely hopeless; to do so would suggest pretty poor judgement on my part.

I actually disagree with you on The Truth not being able to have a positive Zeels match up. It all depends on what attackers you're running of course, but Trainer locks takes its toll and with a charged up Terrakion or two, you can keep tearing through their Lightning-Pokemon. Mewtwo EX can cause problems, but it certainly isn't impossible for the Ross.dec player to deal with.
 
the speed and consistency of zeels, puts it on top of the tier status. it really depends on how you tech my aera calls for me to play 3 mew2EX, and a tornadus. just by my given meta. i dont think that it has the match everytime with takland but if played well with the right techs can surly take the win consistently.

plus if anyone is attending reginols in san jose California there is about 10+ mewtwo celebi decks going to be played...on the UG DL....;)
 
Back
Top